Skip to main content

Health Care Spending Burden of Employer-Sponsored Insurance Beneficiaries by Income

Man fills in form at hospital reception desk with pregnant partner
Assessing differences in health care spending among ESI enrollees by income category and spending quintile
  • Client
    The Commonwealth Fund
  • Dates
    September 2023 – April 2025

Problem

Employer-sponsored insurance research often doesn’t account for varying incomes. 

Although there has been a lot of research on the Employer-Sponsored Insurance (ESI) population, much of it pools individuals with different incomes into the same group. This approach masks important differences in health care spending between groups. Most ESI plans currently provide equal coverage for all workers within a firm, regardless of salary, which can lead to some workers being “underinsured.” For individuals with limited incomes, the budgetary burden of unaffordable health care costs can force tradeoffs between health care and other essential needs.

The Commonwealth Fund realized that more research was needed on granular patterns of health care expenditures of ESI enrollees by income—especially the financial strain faced by those in certain income brackets—to better understand the financial landscape.  

Solution

NORC mined national survey data to study ESI health care burdens by income.

NORC used nationally representative data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation to examine the health care spending burden on ESI enrollees of varying incomes. We descriptively examined the share of household income spent on health care (premiums and out of pocket expenses) and also looked at the extent to which individuals were affected by varying degrees of (prespecified) spending burden.

Result

ESI beneficiaries of all incomes still struggle with health care costs.

NORC’s findings showed that health care spending varies widely both in dollar amounts and as a percentage of income across various income levels and spending categories. However, while high health care costs and increased burdens disproportionately affected lower-income groups, they also hurt higher-income individuals. The following policies could help those in need:

  • Offering sliding-scale ESI premiums for lower-income workers 
  • Expanding Medicaid eligibility
  • Increasing federal subsidies for premiums

Our findings can help policymakers, and employers, craft policies to improve the affordability of health care, particularly for those who are hardest hit. Additional research and monitoring of affordability is also needed to ensure that it does not worsen.

Project Leads

Explore NORC Health Projects

Campus Sexual Assault Responses (CSAR)

The first nationally representative study to investigate campuses’ cooperative approaches to addressing sexual assault

Client:

National Institute of Justice

Evaluating the U.S. Military’s Sexual Assault Prevention Programs

Rigorous evaluation of five initiatives aimed at preventing sexual harassment and sexual assault

Funder:

U.S. Department of Defense